Denver Nuggets: Fat Lever vs. Chauncey Billups
Defense
Both of these legends have been heralded for their defense and have at least one All-Defensive team on their resume. However, I believe that there is a clear answer for who the better defender on the Nuggets was.
In six seasons in Denver, Lever amassed 23.8 defensive win shares. In five seasons in Denver, Billups collected 4.7 defensive win shares. That’s a major point to Fat.
Lever had a steal percentage of 3.2%, almost doubling Chauncey’s 1.7%. Fat also averaged 2.5 steals per game, towering over Billups’ 1.1. Lever averaged 2.7 steals per game in a season twice. The highest Chauncey ever averaged in Denver and in his entire career is 1.3. Steals are certainly not the only way to identify an elite defender, but they are definitely helpful.
Lever had a defensive box plus/minus of 2.2 for his Nuggets career. Billups maintained an average DBPM score of -1.9. In fact, in Billups’ entire career he has never posted a positive DBPM. Even in the two years that he was picked for an All-Defensive team(2004-05 and 2005-06), he posted DBPM scores of -0.9 and -2.2 respectively.
In Denver, Lever posted a defensive rating of 105 per 100 possessions, which is the ninth best score in Denver history among players who have played 250+ games. Billups posted a score of 111 per 100 possessions, which is the 5th worst score in Nuggets history among players who have played 250+ games.
So while these two were among the best defending point guards of their respective generations, it’s pretty clear that Lever was the better defender, at least on the Nuggets.